
Front gate to historic Randwood Estate in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario – a focus of a battle to protect and preserve the town’s heritage.
“Niagara-on-the-Lake is a gem. Our historic capital, its history of European settlement goes back to the Loyalists. Set on the shore of Lake Ontario, surrounded by vineyards, it is a hub of history, culture and tourism. In the 2018 municipal election, development of the old town was very much debated. A focus of the debate was one particular developer (not the Applicant) who provoked discussion by cutting down old trees on his estate.” – Ontario Court Justice Mr. James Ramsay
A News Release from SORE (Save Our Rand Estate), a citizen’s group in Niagara-on-the-Lake
Posted April 23rd, 2021 on Niagara At Large

Tree cutting at the historic Randwood Estate property in Niagara-on-the-Lake three years ago infuriated many town citizens and paved the way to legal action.
SORE is pleased to report on a decision last week of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice of relevance to both the Rand Estate and to heritage protection in NOTL
Hummell Properties, owned by a well- known local developer, had brought an application to quash an interim control by-law enacted by your elected Council in December of 2018, at its first meeting following the most recent municipal election. Hummel claimed bad faith and illegality by the Town in enacting the by-law. The application was heard over two days in St. Catherines last week.
The decision was issued the very next day by Mr. Justice Ramsay, who was clearly unimpressed by application. He made quick work of the allegation of illegality, dismissing it in one paragraph and then characterized the applicant’s evidence on bad faith as “contrived”.

One of a number of rallies, held by SORE and its supporters over the past five or six years, in support of preserving the historic Rand Estate in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario as a heritage site for now and future generations.
His Honour held as follows with respect to the bad faith argument:
“I think that council wanted to preserve the old town’s heritage and that it considered the matter urgent. They wanted to fulfil the mandate that they thought they had been given by the public. They froze the status quo, considered studies and public input, amended the Official Plan and then repealed the interim control by-law. That is essentially what they were supposed to do.” – Mr. Justice James Ramsay Continue reading →
Share this: Niagara At Large at wwwlniagaraatlarge.com