Firing of Another Respected NPCA Employee Draws Public Anger, Concern

Sacking of Employee Proceeds Even as New NPCA Board Passed A Freeze on Staff Hirings and Firings

A News Commentary by Niagara At Large reporter and publisher Doug Draper

Posted February 12th, 2019 on Niagara At Large

Stuart McPherson, a respected watershed restoration projects worker at the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority is the latest rank-and-file employee to get axed at the controversial agency

Meet the new NPCA board, same as the old NPCA board.

That’s the way it seems to be going, unfortunately. Nothing much has changed since the old Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority (NPCA) finally took a hike and since last December 6th, when Niagara’s Regional Council appointed 12 members of the council last December 6th to sit on the Conservation Authority’s board for an interim period of three months.

In fact, things seem to have been getting worse over the past couple of months at a Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority (NPCA) that – to borrow a word Ontario Superior Court Justice James Ramsey used this past December on this problem-plagued agency – has been a textbook study in “chaos” for some time now.

Within the past couple of weeks alone, there was an appearance of David Barrick, a former Port Colborne regional councillor and currently the NPCA’s controversial “acting” or “interim” CAO, before Niagara Region’s budget review committee that raised the ire of a number of councillors for failing to answer key questions about the NPCA’s finances.

Barrick stood before the regional councillors with a budget demanding more than eight million tax dollars from the region, and said: “This is not a request for approval (of the money). The   Region’s council, he continued, has little or no choice but to give the NPCA the money without the Conservation Authority having to provide the council with the level of financial detail that other agencies, like the police, do.

NPCA’s “acting CAO” David Barrick

Then there were reports of a complaint phoned in to Niagara Regional Police from, according to a police spokesperson, someone at the NPCA alleging that a citizens group called A Better Niagara had posted on social media some threatening words about Barrick following his performance at the Region’s budget meeting.

The NRP rapidly concluded that there was nothing about the criticism the citizens group posted that warranted the laying of charges or any further action by police.

Indeed, in an Open Letter that Niagara Centre MPP Jeff Burch sent to members of the NPCA board this February 11th, he had this to say about that phone call –

“Last week,” wrote Burch, “senior members of the NPCA staff called the police over a Facebook post. The post did not contain any threats towards any members of the NPCA or its staff. Police cannot be used to intimidate critics, and I am disappointed that once again the NPCA has used extreme measures in an attempt to silence dissent.”

A now we have learned this.

Sometime in the past number of days, even after the NPCA’s board approved a motion this past January 7th putting at least a temporary freeze on hirings and firings at the agency, an NPCA employee named Stuart McPherson, who is highly respected among his colleagues in the conservation field and who had been doing some key work in the watershed restoration area for the Conservation Authority, has been fired.

NPCA employee Stuart McPherson was let go under a board of directors that was supposed to be better, but is rapidly becoming a bad joke under the chairmanship of this guy in middle of the above image – West Lincoln Mayor Dave Bylsma who is also a member of a fringe political party called the ChristIan Heritage Party that doubts the science behind climate change. Imagine that. Thanks to our new Niagara Regional Council, we now have a chair of what is supposed to be an agency that looks after our natural environment who belongs to a fringe party that shuns climate science.

That’s right!

Even after all of the reports about questionable firings of several other NPCA employees in the past (discussed in a scorching report Ontario Auditor General Bonnie Lysyk released on the Conservation Authority last September) and even after that hiring freeze motion the new board past this January, McPherson was fired for reasons we have yet to get to the bottom of.

Niagara At Large reached out to a few NPCA board members earlier this February 12 for information on McPherson’s sacking, but to little or no avail.

I am unable to comment on personnel matters,” responded Pelham Regional Councillor and the NPCA board’s co-chair Diana Huson in an email. “I can tell you a special meeting will occur on Friday.”

Tim Whelan, a Thorold Regional Councillor who also sits on the board, also declined to offer any details about McPherson’s departure from the agency. He would only add that the matter will be discussed by board members at the special meeting called for this February 15th.

Stuart McPherson was a restoration technician at the NPCA, working in partnership with community groups in Niagara to improve the health of One Mile Creek in Niagara-on-the-Lake with a “Friends of” the creek there, and on similar projects across the region.

Word of McPherson’s demise at the NPCA has already triggered concern and anger from individual citizens and groups across Niagara.

Ed Smith, a St. Catharines community activist and a director of A Better Niagara who has been watchdogging operations at the NPCA for more than three years now, shared the following response with Niagara At Large

Ed Smith, a St. Catharines citizen and community activist,defeated a lawsuit filed against him two years ago by the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority after he raised concerns about the way that body spends our tax money. Smith is now a director of the citizens group, A Better Niagara.

“On January 7th, the NPCA board passed a motion that directed in part, ‘the interim CAO to freeze all hiring, firing, and changes to organizational structure unless approved by the Board until a permanent CAO is appointed,’ responded Smith in an email. “Now we find out that not only are they recruiting new people, but they have fired yet another employee.”

“This is shocking,” added Smith. “This was a public motion passed by the Board and there has been no public motion passed to remove the freeze on hiring and firing, so how is this happening?”

“There are only two options that I can surmise,” said Smith. “Either the interim CAO (David Barrick) is working on his own in contravention of the Board, or the Board approved such actions behind the scenes, in-camera.”

“Both of these options are unacceptable. These types of actions should not be discussed in-camera. The motion to freeze firings was a public motion because it is the public’s business. If the board is removing that restriction that also should be discussed in public, and under no circumstances should the CAO be allowed to take unilateral actions within the NPCA.

“The public cannot stand by and watch this happen,” concluded Smith “We hoped that (last October’s municipal) election and appointment of a new Board would end the tyranny of the old regime.”

“Instead we see it perpetuating itself in a Board that is adrift with no leadership coming from the Chair.  It’s time for citizens to get re-engaged in the issues of the NPCA. It’s also time for this Board to start questioning its leadership.”

Niagara At Large will be posting more on this and related matters involving the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority and what our Niagara Regional Council and other parties are or are not doing to address the ongoing chaos here in the days ahead.

Stay tuned.

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space following the Bernie Sanders quote below.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater bi-national Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

“A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders

5 responses to “Firing of Another Respected NPCA Employee Draws Public Anger, Concern

  1. Robert Milenkoff

    Words cannot explain what is going on at the NPCA. Having a new board could be compared to having a new pair of shoes …………………….. just because they are new doesn’t mean they are any good. A supervisor should have been brought in 2 years ago like a number of municipalities voted for but it seems that would have been too easy.
    Robert Milenkoff


  2. I don’t know whether to laugh or cry. The board is shamefully negligent to the taxpayers of Niagara and surrounding areas.


  3. Rosemary Johnstone

    HELP!! Over and over the NPCA proves they are NOT listening


  4. Just a point. I know at least 2 members of the current board, and trust them. If there is a hiring/firing freeze (and there is) they’d stick to it.

    On the other hand, the acting CAO is already provably shady, and without respect for the boards oversight. Staffing is actually the responsibility of the CAO, not the board. They only manage the CAO.


  5. Words cannot express the sadness/anger I feel right now as we lose yet another protector of our watersheds of Niagara! I have had the privilege working alongside Stuart not only on projects along Walker’s Creek Trails, but throughout Niagara as well. His willingness to share his expertise and his passion for the environment is the “cement” in the foundation of many volunteer groups across Niagara!
    Della Trojan, Chairperson
    The Friends of Walker’s Creek


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.