Urgent Action Needed – New Ontario Government Act Allows Private For-Profit Hospitals & More Private For-Profit Clinics 

Please read and Act on this Information, and share this information widely with your friends and associates

A Call to Action from the Ontario Health Coalition, a province-wide citizen advocacy group

Posted November 24th, 2017 on Niagara At Large

The Ontario government is moving forward with legislation that lifts the ban on private hospitals, rolls private hospitals in with private clinics and renames them, offensively, Community Health Facilities, and makes it easier for private hospitals and clinics to expand and more difficult for the Minister to stop them.

This legislation was brought in with no prior public consultation. It is a massive omnibus bill that repeals or enacts 7 entire Acts, and amends more than 30 Acts. We were given 5 minutes to present to the Standing Committee on this massive piece of legislation. Now we have only four days to try to get the worst part of it withdrawn. Without due consideration of the consequences, the government is making a grave mistake that could easily usher in very significant new privatization and threats to our local public hospitals.

Please email or call your MPP and ask them to help withdraw Schedule 9 of Bill 160. They need to act by early next week.

I have pasted the Open Letter that we just issued to all Members of Provincial Parliament below. It provides a succinct briefing. I have also attached a more extensive brief on Bill 160 for your information.

Thank you for your urgent help in this important matter for all Ontarians. The principles that public health care be provided safely, in the public domain, for people not for profit are shared by millions of Ontarians. Please help us make sure that our MPPs understand that this issue cannot be ignored.

Natalie Mehra, Executive Director, Ontario  Health Coalition

Here is a link to the Ontario Legislative Assembly website where there is a list of MPPs with their contact information:


Here is the Open Letter we, at the Ontario Health Coalition, just issued:

Open Letter to All Ontario MPPs

 November 23, 2017

Dear Members of Provincial Parliament,

We are writing to urgently draw your attention to a bill before our Legislature that holds very grave implications for all Ontario communities. Bill 160 is an omnibus piece of legislation that repeals or enacts 7 Acts and amends more than 30 Acts.

The Bill has been brought in with no prior public consultation despite its far-reaching ramifications.  We have a number of concerns with the Bill as it is drafted but we are taking the exceptional step of writing an open letter to every Member of Provincial Parliament because we are deeply concerned about Schedule 9 of the Bill.

Schedule 9 repeals the Private Hospitals Act, the Independent Health Facilities Act and the Healing Arts Radiation Protection Act. It replaces them with euphemistically named “Community Health Facilities”. These changes cover more than 900 private clinics — more than 98 percent of which are not “community health facilities” but are in fact private for-profit clinics and often chain-owned — and 6 private for-profit hospitals.

The Private Hospitals Act was brought in in 1973 and banned all future private hospitals. It empowers the Minister of Health to have wide latitude in oversight of private hospitals, and in particular, enables the Minister to revoke licenses and refuse transfers.

These powers are critically important. When one of the largest for-profit multinational mega-health companies in the world tried to move in and buy the Shouldice Hospital, advocates were able to ask the Minister to intervene under this Act. Crucially, the Private Hospitals Act has effected a ban on private hospitals for 44 years in this province.

Schedule 9 of Bill 160 lifts the ban on private hospitals and does not replace it. Without due consideration, the government is rolling in private hospitals, which allow admissions and overnight stays, with private clinics which do not. This has very dangerous implications.

The definition is left to the regulations. Further, an appointed person in the bureaucracy will have the power, with the stroke of a pen, to bring in new private clinics and, now, since they are rolled into the Act, private hospitals. Problems under the current private clinics regime include: patient deaths; serious safety breaches that have risked, among other things, potential infection of more than a thousand patients with HIV/AIDs; other serious health care quality concerns; for-profit privatization of our local hospital services; new user fees for patients in violation of the Canada Health Act; unnecessary testing, and others.

None of the problems under the current legislation is improved under Bill 160 Schedule 9, including oversight, inspections and safety regime, for-profit privatization and user fees for patients. Virtually everything is left to regulation. Key clauses in the existing pieces of legislation have been dropped, including vital public protection against user fees for patients and safety protections for ionizing radiation (x-rays).

We consider this a top priority issue. If the government lifts the 44-year ban on private hospitals in Ontario and brings in permissive legislation to privatize Ontario’s hospital services, we will do our utmost to stop it. We do not want to have to go down that road and are asking for your help in getting Schedule 9 withdrawn at the beginning of next week. Thank you for your consideration of this serious issue.

Kind Regards,

Natalie Mehra                                                                   Ross Sutherland

Executive Director                                                           Chair

 – Protecting Public Medicare for All ~

For more information on  the Ontario Health Coalition and its citizen advocacy work for public health care in the province, click on –  www.ontariohealthcoalition.ca
NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space below the Bernie quote.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater binational Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at www.niagaraatlarge.com .

“A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.