U.S., Canada Must Keep Their Relationship Special – A View from Buffalo, New York

Another Voice on Cross-border relations

By Kerry Mitchell

Posted July 12th, 2021 on Niagara At Large

A year or so before the pandemic started, signs like this began appearing on lawns in Buffalo neighbourhoods. Buffalo residents were trying to assure us that regardless of anything Trump had to say about Canada, they considered us to be friends.

After a career with the Consulate General of Canada in Buffalo, where I regularly wrote speeches, op-eds, etc., on the Canada-U.S. relationship for the consuls general under which I served, it is time again to put pen to paper on this theme – but this time as a concerned citizen, and under my own name.

Born American, but with the privilege of spending summers on the Canadian shores of Lake Erie, I always felt a special connection to Canada. That feeling amplified when working at the Canadian Consulate, where border issues were the lifeblood of our work.

Shared interests would bring folks together, but the personal relationships that formed provided the sustaining spirit.

These networks regularly gave voice (while generating some good fun) to the many ways that Canada and the U.S. were “in it together” – a framing of interest that would ultimately serve both countries. I am worried that we – at the national, regional and individual level – are losing that feel of “in it together.

” In the past, this natural orientation for some has led to finding creative ways to work some things out for our friends and neighbors – because we cared and because we could. In recent years, we’ve heard more strident comments coming from both sides over controversial issues and individuals, and seen more rigid lines drawn around policy and positions. And now the pandemic has created new situations that have raised the heat on the relationship.

I am cognizant of the fraughtness of the time that we have all been living under the pandemic.

But still I ask: Why didn’t we – Americans and Canadians – try to do more where we could? If liability issues prevented the U.S. from being able to send more vaccine to Canada, why didn’t we find creative ways to get some Canadians the shot right at the U.S. border?

Such a gesture would have touched many hearts, even if only a few arms. And why couldn’t both countries find more workable arrangements for children, parents and dedicated lovers to meet during this time?

And why after more than a year of the border being closed is it still politic in Canada to prevent fully vaccinated property owners from visiting their properties across the border? It’s not that these issues have not been given voice – but rather, it is the seeming lack of interest to try to ease these situations for our friends and neighbors where we could that suggests a widening rift.

We in the border regions have a natural role and an important stake in the people-to-people relations between our countries, as well as the larger relationship as a whole. Where we can, let’s keep it special.

 Kerry Mitchell is former manager of the Political/Economic Affairs Section of the Consulate General Canada, Buffalo.

A Brief Footnote from Niagara At Large reporter and publisher Doug Draper –

I came to follow the work of Kerry Mitchell more than two decades ago, while I will still employed as an environment reporter at The St. Catharines Standard.

I was immediately impressed with her full-hearted determination to address the concerns of Canadians and Americans alike over any threat to the health of our shared boundary waters in the Great Lakes.

Then U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton addresses Americans and Canadians in the middle of the Rainbow Bridge in Niagara Falls as both countries celebrated the anniversary of the Canada/U.S. Boundary Waters Treaty in 2009. Kerry Mitchell played a key role through the Canadian Consulate office in Buffalo in organizing the celebration.

Kerry Mitchell and her colleagues at the Canadian Consulate office in Buffalo, New York had a great deal to do with celebrating, in 2009,  the 100th anniversary of the Canada/U.S. Boundary Waters Treaty – the first treaty of its kind in the world to protect waters shared by two or more nations. The celebrations brought citizens and political leaders on both sides of the border together in a raising awareness  of how much the fresh waters of the Great Lakes mean to the health of people and communities in both countries.

Then, a few years later, Canada’s Conservative Harper government shut down the Consulate office in Buffalo, which helped Canadians in so many other ways around cross-border business. One of the supporters of killing this great office was then Niagara Falls MP and Harper Cabinet minister, Rob Nicholson – just one more act of shameless cowtailing to Harper that Nicholson should never be forgiven for.

Think of how much of a role this Consulate office could be playing today as neighbouring Canadian and American communities work to find ways of trying to bring family and friends back together during this COVID nightmare.

So thank you to Kerry Mitchell for still carrying enough to speak out about the special relationship our neighbouring communities have and hope to keep.

  • Doug Draper, Niagara At Large

NIAGARA AT LARGE Encourages You To Join The Conversation By Sharing Your Views On This Post In The Space Following The Bernie Sanders Quote Below.

“A Politician Thinks Of The Next Election. A Leader Thinks Of The Next Generation.” – Bernie Sanders


2 responses to “U.S., Canada Must Keep Their Relationship Special – A View from Buffalo, New York

  1. Important opinion piece I hope is widely read at Queen’s Park and on Capital Hill. In spite of recent irritants, a “special” relationship with the US is critical for frontier communities and leads to greater prosperity on both sides of the border.


  2. I totally respect Kerry Mitchell’s perspective. From personal experience, I have seen her work tirelessly on behalf of our shared border region. As a dual citizen living in Canada but having worked for many years in the U.S., I too am troubled by the lack of effort to develop creative solutions to the impacts of COVID to benefit both sides of the river. This has been a wildly scary and confusing time for the entire world, and it was not surprising that respective federal, provincial and state governments were not able to mount a coordinated response. At this point in time, however, I am especially concerned with Canada’s reluctance to follow science with regard to allowing passage of fully vaccinated individuals across the border, and hope that our federal government will take appropriate action soon. Thank you for your insights, Kerry Mitchell!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.