The Craven Cowardice of Lincoln’s Mayor and Town Council

Niagara town council offers not a word of support for one of Lincoln’s gold star citizens

A Commentary by Doug Draper

Posted July 19th, 2-17 on Niagara At Large

Silence becomes cowardice when occasion demands speaking out the whole truth and acting accordingly. – Mahatma Gandhi

Niagara, Ontario – Lincoln Mayor Sandra Easton and her town council had at least two opportunities to publicly speak out in support of one of their town’s most respected and dedicated public servants and citizens. And both times, they did not.

Town of Lincoln Mayor Sandra Easton.

That public servant and citizen is Bill Hodgson, a Lincoln regional councillor a mayor and school board trustee for the municipality who, until recently, also served as one of 15 appointed members on the board of directors for the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority.

This spring, a majority of the other 14 NPCA board members – a majority of them elected Niagara mayors and councillors appointed by Niagara’s regional council – went behind closed doors like the snivelling cowards and creeps most of them are and voted to “censure” Bill Hodgson – as in slam the guy with a formal expression of disapproval tantamount to a pillorying or shaming – for reasons many of the rest of us do not understand.

What many of the rest of us do understand is that Bill Hodgson, who responded to that crappy treatment – quite understandably – by tendering his resignation from the board, is that up to the time he was censure, he was the only member of that board earnestly championing a call by numerous Niagara residents and by a number of municipal councils in Niagara and Hamilton for a thorough, independent audit of the NPCA’s operations.

The calls for this audit, by the way, have been driven by questions and concerns that have been raised in the public realm for well over a year now about how this Conservation Authority is spending millions of our tax dollars.

Lincoln regional councillor and now former NPCA board member Bill Hodgson

As much as the censuring of Bill Hodgson upset and angered a good many members of the public across this region, but this past June, when Sandy Annunziata, a Fort Erie regional councillor and  chair of the NPCA board, stood before Lincoln Mayor Sandra Easton and her council to outline what the Conservation Authority now is, and what it isn’t under his watch – “we are not an environmental protection agency,” Annunziata was quoted saying at one point – the council did not raise a peep about the shaming of their fellow citizen.

“Councillors steered clear of questioning Annunziata about recent turmoil at the board level regarding Lincoln regional councillor Bill Hodgson,” read a report of the Lincoln council meeting in a June 23rd edition of the Grimsby Lincoln News.

Then, this past July 17th, at another meeting of Lincoln council, the mayor and councillors discussed what to do about filling Bill Hodgson’s now vacant seat on the NPCA board – a matter they ultimately decided to defer to a future meeting – the council once again had nothing to say about the disgusting way Hodgson was treated.

A report of the June 17th meeting, posted the same day on the St. Catharines Standard’s online news site, read as follows; “Asked whether the circumstances surrounding Hodgson’s departure from the board is a concern = including the board’s refusal to disclose what Hodgson is alleged to have done = Easton and the town council decided to stay out of it. … ‘If it happens again in the future, we will deal with it at that time,’ she (Easton) said.”

If it happens again in the future? What in hell does that mean? Madam Mayor, what about the awful garbage that is going down right now!

I am far from the only one who has noticed a coarsening of conduct at the municipal level of government in Niagara over the past two or three years. That is disturbing enough.

Even more heartening though is how few of our councillors at the regional and local levels are demonstrating the courage to stand up to all of this insulting and bullying behaviour.

To many of our municipal councillors are enabling this disgusting conduct by doing just what Easton and her council have done, not once, but twice now within as many months, and not showing the courage to stand up for what is left of decency and civility in public life.

To read a related story on this mess, posted this past May in Niagara At Large, click on .

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space below the Bernie quote.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater bi-national Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

“A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders

3 responses to “The Craven Cowardice of Lincoln’s Mayor and Town Council

  1. “Conservation Authority”
    It may not be an USA ‘Environmental Protection Authority’ but it IS meant to Conserve wet and wild lands so that the public neither loses what we have now nor needs to pay horrendous future flooding costs because people were allowed to build on floodplains. Most of Niagara was marshland when the Loyalists arrived, and all low areas should always remain as undeveloped farm and forest.

    As our climate changes in unpredictable directions, we need to know that these low areas are there to collect water in the 100-year storms that seem to be happening more often.

    Hear, hear! to protecting the reputations of politicians who express contrary opinions, whether we like them or not. Bill Hodgson should Not have resigned when censured. Who is now on the NPCA board to ask questions?


  2. I was at the Meeting of the NPCA when this disgraceful lack of intestinal fortitude took place and I was totally astonished to see there was a complete lack of guts displayed by a few people I once admired, one of which, a mayor who just sat there as if it were a normal meeting. Thank God there is an election taking place next year and just maybe there will be a wholesale clean out of vermin who have managed to totally infested the governance of our Niagara. Thank You Doug I realize it is a can of worms that responds with threats and Lawuits But like you and the ones who got involved I admire your tenacity and desire for accountability…It is a shame the LIBERAL GOVERNMENT in Queens Park has such a lack of concern for the people who are Citizens of Ontario for they could have stepped in a year or so ago.


  3. It appears that the Town of Lincoln believes that the chair of the NPCA can determine what is best for their municipality. Sandy Annunziata, a Fort Erie regional councillor and chair of the NPCA board, stood before Lincoln Mayor Sandra Easton and her council to outline what the Conservation Authority now is, and what it isn’t under his watch – “WE ARE NOT AN ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY”, Annunziata was quoted saying at one point – the council did not raise a peep about the shaming of their fellow citizen. Does the Mayor and town council care about the environment or about conservation in the Niagara Region?
    Thank you Mr Hodgson for trying to do the right thing.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.