Niagara Falls By-Election May Decide Tim Hudak’s Fate As Tory Leader

A Commentary by Doug Draper

Well here we finally are. It is Thursday, February 13th and it is finally up to voters across the provincial Riding of Niagara Falls to decide who is going to be their next MPP.

Niagara Falls Tory candidate Bart Maves with the party's leader, Tim Hudak, at one of many media events over the past several months.

Niagara Falls Tory candidate Bart Maves with the party’s leader, Tim Hudak, at one of many media events over the past several months.

The riding, which includes Niagara Falls and the neighbouring towns of Fort Erie and Niagara-on-the-Lake has been hotly contested by all three major parties – the Liberals, which held it for 10 years until Kim Craitor suddenly decided to get out of provincial politics last year, the Conservatives and NDP – and no one has worked longer and harder to win the riding than Tory candidate Bart Maves and the party’s leader Tim Hudak. 

While all three candidates – Liberal Joyce Morocco, NDP Wayne Gates, both Niagara Falls city councillors, and Maves, a regional councillor for Niagara Falls who was the riding’s MPP for two terms during Tory Premier Mike Harris’s years – were officially nominated by their Falls riding associations only a few weeks ago, Maves has been the presumed candidate for the Tories for the better part of a year now. What’s more, Hudak, whose old hometown is Fort Erie, has hardly let a week go by over the past three or four months where he hasn’t been out there, working the riding with Maves. Media advisories from PC headquarters, alerting editors and reporters to yet another heads up on a Hudak/Maves announcement and/or photo opportunity somewhere in the riding, have come fast and furious as last Fall turned to this Winter. So Hudak has invested one helluva lot of time and energy in working the Niagara Falls Riding with his former Tory caucus mate Maves as he hopes to get him back into the caucus again. 

Only problem is that the race in Niagara Falls is almost too close to call with Gates, who only got into it three weeks ago, giving Maves the most run for his money. In fact, one poll reported in The Toronto Star and Globe and Mail over the past couple of days, has gates leading by 48 per cent, with Maves trailing at 33 per cent and Morocco far behind at 17 per cent.

Of course polls are polls, and they have been wrong before. But if this one, conducted by Forum Research and the only one that has surfaced publicly to date, is right, a loss for Hudak in his old backyard, even if his party wins another by-election this February 13th, as it is expected it will, in the Toronto area riding of Norfolk, it could be a real body blow to his leadership in the  party. 

Indeed, if Hudak can’t win his old sidekick another seat at Queen’s Park in his home turf, how confident will a provincial Conservative Party, that is already internally debating his Tea Party-like union busting strategies, feel about him leading it into a general election, that could come as early as this spring? 

Would the party even want to make any further moves to defeat the minority Liberal government of Kathleen Wynne with Hudak as a leader. 

If Hudak can’t win the Niagara Falls Riding this February 13th after all the many months of work he and his old party comrade Maves have put into it, then many in his party may feel that his wanting to draw the Liberals and NDP into a general election with him as leader might be something akin to General Custer baiting for a fight at the Little Big Horn.

(Niagara At Large invites you to share your views on this post. A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who share their first and last name with them.)


3 responses to “Niagara Falls By-Election May Decide Tim Hudak’s Fate As Tory Leader

  1. This Election, could be the kiss of death for Tim Hudak,I noticed at both Candidates nights that i attended, the natives (residents of Niagara) are very upset and angry, about the treatment the Liberal Party has bestowed upon them, number # 1 the Drummond Report that decimated Fort Erie and threatened the very incubator of Tourism in Niagara falls.the failure to stop Can-Gro from pulling up stakes and taking with them the millions in tax payer grants and our jobs with them, also the shabby treatment that our Kim Craitor got from the Liberal Party, number #2 the stupidity they showed when they allowed our hospitals to be closed by NHS and the LHINS . Hundreds of people died because of their mishandling of this deal.Tim was weak and ineffectual in putting our case forward. He is not suited for prime time in my opinion.


  2. I may be criticized for this, but now that I have seen the results of the by-elections, I am very happy that the NDP took the Niagara Falls riding!
    The Conservatives held on to the Thornhill riding, but that is not a major surprise. Many folks in that area were born with PC branded into their backsides!
    I truly hope Tim Hudak gets the message – even in his home riding, where he grew up, his candidate couldn’t get elected. His type of divisive, negative politics is not wanted.
    The fact Bart Maves came second was due to Bart Maves – NOT Hudak.
    It will be interesting to see if Tim-bit keeps pushing for an early election. Then again, he might. It would be a quick and easy way for him to get out of the party leadership! He will be out on his keester with any more defeats!


  3. George You are right on and the fact that Hudak has adopted the ‘Tea Party” political style just might have been his final faux pas…The Conservative Party Candidate, Maves along with Hudah never, that I am aware of, showed their faces in Support of the peoples of Fort Erie, Port Colborne or even Welland and Niagara Falls when we were fighting to save our hospitals and as such they got what they deserves “REJECTION” from the PEOPLE.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s