By Doug Draper
The chances of the headquarters for Niagara, Ontario’s police services remaining in downtown St. Catharines appear to be growing dimmer ever time the region’s council meets to discuss the subject.

One of the two buildings the Niagara Regional Police occupy now in downtown St. Catharines. Possibly soon to be evacuated. Photo by Doug Draper.
This June 24, a majority on the council swept a report by St. Catharines Mayor Brian McMullan aside, making an 11th hour case for keeping the Niagara Regional Police Services’ headquarters in the downtown of his city. Following hours of discussion behind closed doors, the council decided instead to consider sites for a new police headquarters in Niagara Falls and other undisclosed locations.
Where ever a new police headquarters goes, it could cost the taxpayers of Niagara, Ontario as much as $100 million or more – possibly the largest capital expenditure for any single facility the region has approved in its 40-year history.
While no one on the region’s council is publicly disclosing sites for the new facilities, the current rumor is that the preferred location is in Niagara Falls, off Harold Stone Road and Stanley Avenue, on a ‘Brownfield’ where the old Cyanamid plant was located.
If the police headquarters is ultimately moved out of St. Catharine’s and the city altogether, it will obviously be a blow to that city’s downtown. At the very least it will mean another loss of many high-paying, professional employees from the city’s core – people who frequented local restaurants and perhaps spent a little time shopping downtown before returning to whatever suburb of whatever municipality in Niagara they live in.
But then, this isn’t the first time St. Catharine’s has lost and will continue to lose high-paid jobs in and near its downtown core. A mere six years ago, the city’s council still had a chance to put up a fight to put a 21st century hospital complex downtown, when the Niagara Health System was pushing to locate it on the fringes of the municipality, beyond a jungle of big box stores in west St. Catharine’s.
So one might reply to McMullen and company, why get all high and might now, and insist that a major public institution remain in an urban center, according to the province’s ‘Places to Grow’ plans, when there was no interest on the part of your city to keep an institution as significant as a hospital downtown? Who are you representing? The interests of your downtown or those who are profiting from this hospital being built on old west St. Catharines farmland, where developers have been having a field day speculating on the lands around it?
In other words, never mind trying to impress the province or the public with the idea that a major public institution like the police headquarters should remain in the city’s downtown. On the hospital file, you’ve already blown it!
So here are in Niagara, with our regional councillors working to decide where a new police headquarters for the region – one that could cost us $100 million or more – should go.
Among the questions we should continue to be asking are these – ‘Do we really need to move the regional headquarters out of St. Catharines and why? Why can’t the current buildings be made to work? And if we do need a new location, why can’t the public have a say in where, at least generally, a new headquarters , should go?
In other words, why can’t we, as the taxpayers finally have some say in this matter after all the closed door sessions our duly elected regional councillors have had? Why can’t we?
(Click on Niagara At Large at www.niagaraatlarge.com for more news and commentary of interest to residents in our greater Niagara region.)