Another Niagara Municipality – This time the City of Port Colborne – Joins Call To Ontario Government For Audit of Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority

Province Should Step In With Special Supervisor NOW And Sweep Out Entire NPCA Board & Administration

A News Commentary by Doug Draper

Posted just after Midnight on December 13th, 2016 on Niagara At Large

This just recently in.

The council for the City of Port Colborne – as of this evening of Monday, December 12th  – has joined the City of St. Catharines and Town of Niagara-on-the-Lake in unanimously supporting a motion calling on the Ontario government to conduct a full investigation and forensic audit of the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority’s operations

Ed Smith at Niagara's regional council this past spring, asking it to order an audit of the NPCA, and getting treated like human garbage in return by some of the council members. File photo by Doug Draper

Ed Smith at Niagara’s regional council this past spring, asking it to order an audit of the NPCA, and getting treated like human garbage in return by some of the council members. File photo by Doug Draper

..The Niagara-on-the-Lake council approved such a motion earlier on the same Monday evening, and now Port Colborne, with Niagara Falls city council scheduled to consider a similar motion this coming Tuesday, December 13th, and other municipal councils in Niagara, Ontario expected to follow suit before the end of this year.

This unprecedented call by municipalities in Niagara for a forensic audit of a publicly funded body in the region follows in the wake of a call Welland Riding MPP Cindy Forster made to the province this November for an audit of the NPCA, and in the wake of a growing lack of public confidence in those running this Conservation Authority.

It also follows news that the NPCA’s board directed a lawyer to send a letter to St. Catharines citizen Ed Smith – someone who has been asking for a thorough audit of the Conservation Authority’s since this past spring – threatening him with a lawsuit for circulating a report raising questions and concerns about hirings, firings, the tendering of contracts and other matters involving this body and its way of conducting business with millions of dollars of our money.

As Ed Smith, a community volunteer and 25-year veteran of the Canadian Armed Forces, said at a press conference he hosted in St. Catharines following news of the lawsuit -threat, “Those who have nothing to hide, hide nothing.”

“If the NPCA has nothing to hide then let them come public with the documents we have requested, and let them respond directly to the well documented concerns that have occurred since 2013 and continue to this day,” added Smith during the November 30th press conference. “My assertion remains that the NPCA has strayed far from its mandate; it has become an organization encrusted with a sense of impunity and therefore it steadfastly refuses any attempt from citizens for openness, transparency and fairness.”

Michael Welsh, who serves as chair of Niagara-on-the-Lake’s committee of adjustment, but who brought forward a motion to the council of his town as a private citizen this December 12th, told Niagara At Large during an interview earlier in the day that the lawsuit threat against Ed Smith was the “last straw” for him around concerns he already shared with others about the NPCA and the way it does business. A threat like that, stressed Welsh, “is a chill for any citizen” who may wish to exercise their democratic right to question government bodies and how they use our tax dollars.

It is, indeed!

And it is high time that the Premier of Ontario, Kathleen Wynne, and the province’s Minister of Natural Resources and Forestry, Kathryn McGarry, recognize that the growing questions and concerns raised by citizens across this Niagara region and neighbouring Hamilton, and the cascading calls, starting with Hamilton’s city council last year, and continuing with municipalities in Niagara, for a forensic audit and other actions.

Time is now overdue for the Ontario government to hire a special supervisor to come in and clear this NPCA board, along with the body's upper management, out. File photo by Doug Draper

Time is now overdue for the Ontario government to hire a special supervisor to come in and clear this NPCA board, along with the body’s upper management, out. File photo by Doug Draper

It is high time the Premier, the Minister and their government recognize these clarion calls and  take the steps necessary to give the public back a Conservation Authority it can respect as the open, response voice for protecting and preserving what is left of our natural heritage that this region needs and deserves.

This should not only include a full forensic, value for dollar audit of the NPCA’s operations but the appointment of a special supervisor under the legislative powers the provincial has to come in and completely sweep out the board and upper management of this body.

A few years ago, I sat at a meeting hosted by the NPCA in Thorold where, shortly after the honchoes running the Conservation Authority fired a group of its field workers, a consultant it hired to work on its strategic plan stood in front of members of the board and members of the community, and used names like “ideologues” and “sandpaper” to describe those employees who were now out of work and looking for another job.

I had never before heard or seen representatives of a public body or anyone working for such a body on contract openly pillory people it had recently let go or fired like that. It was a disgusting display that I witnessed with several others I know would still come forward and vouch for the fact that it happened.

Quite bluntly, I also know that I am far from the only one who believes that some of the real “ideologues” and “sandpaper” are still there, holding board and management positions in this organization, and it is about time the province stepped in and told them to take a hike.

Much better they get the boot than see more  NPCA staff – the people doing the good work out in the field -possibly losing their jobs or having  breakdowns. .

I encourage everyone across this region who cares about conserving our natural heritage, and about the importance of open, transparent government, and about the right of citizens to ask questions about how our tax money is spent without the fear of being sued, to do a little Google searching on the internet for the contact information for Premier Wynne and the Natural Resources Minister Kathryn McGarry, and urge them to come in and clean up this mess NOW!

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space provided after the Bernie Sanders quote below.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater binational Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

 “A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders


One response to “Another Niagara Municipality – This time the City of Port Colborne – Joins Call To Ontario Government For Audit of Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority

  1. Hi Doug I believe the Township of Wainfleet has also endorsed the call for an audit. And their mayor, Jeffs, is on the NPCA board and says other board members also back the audit call Maybe you had this and I missed it

    A Brief Response from Doug Draper – I am aware of Township of Wainfleet motion for an audit and spent more than half an hour asking Wainfleet Mayor April Jeffs about it and related NPCA matters following its passage in the first week of this December, and I will be dealing with what many others, including this reporter, regard as the “bogus value” of the Wainfleet motion and about the role of Jeffs and other NPCA members in, among other things, launching a harassing legal action against a private citizen for raising questions and concerns in the near future.

    This Wainleet motion, unlike the ones passed in St. Catharines, Niagara-on-the-Lake and Port Colborne and being considered by other Niagara municipalities, fits neatly into the narrative of the NPCA and its board chair, Bruce Timms, as he echoed it earlier this month at a St. Catharines council meeting, that the board would prefer that individuals and groups approach it first (rather than go to other municipal government bodies and the province) with their request for a more thorough, forensic office.

    Of course, the board would prefer this because it accomplishes a number of things. It buys the board more time to put an audit off and it also offers the board the opportunity to say: “yes, we’ll do the audit, so the province does not have to consider doing one.

    Then it comes down to how much trust the public has that the NPCA will have an audit done that offers true transparency in terms of answering the questions and concerns so many citizens have about this body and how it is spending millions of dollars of hour money. From almost everything I am hearing from people across the region, there is little faith out there that the NPCA would do an audit that drills down the areas members of the public want addressed.

    That is one of the major reasons why other municipal councils are looking to the provincial government to arrange a true forensic, value for dollar audit of the NPCA operations. – Doug Draper


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s