Cuts To Hospital Services In Niagara, Ontario And Other Regions Of Province Just Keep On Coming

A Foreword By Niagara At Large

The late Canadian prime minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau once said that the United States is a great place to live if you are young, healthy and wealthy.

Niagara area residents protest hospital cuts in Toronto this April.

One of the matters Trudeau was focusing on when he made that comment was the lack a publicly funded, universal system of health care in the U.S. – the kind of which Canadians have been blessed with now for the better part of 50 years, thanks to the progressive campaigning of a politician named Tommy Douglas.

But thousands of cuts by successive provincial governments, starting with the NDP government of Bob Rae, the Conservative governments of Mike Harris and Ernie Eves, and now the Liberal government of Dalton McGuinty, along with the mismanagement of hospital services by unelected, regional boards like the Niagara Health System, Canada’s system of accessible, quality care for all appears to be heading for its death throes – in this region of the country, at least.

Unelected bodies like the NHS and the Local Health Integration Network (LHIN) for the Niagara and Hamilton regions of the province continueclosing patient beds in our hospitals while the provincial government tries wiping its hands clean of any responsibility.

Niagara At Large has posted many articles on this site – articles you can scan by y visiting –  on citizens’ continued concerns over the mess being made of hospitial services on the Ontario side of the border. And below, we are posting a note by Fiona McMurran, a Welland resident and Niagara representative for the citizens group, Council of Canadians, followed by a report from the Ontario Public Service Employees Union (OPSEU), representing more than 600 health care professionals in Niagara’s hospitals alone.

Please read them and seek out contact information for your provincial representatives, the province’s premier and health minister, and tell them enough is enough. Remind them there is a provincial election next year and a price will be paid for those who sit back and let unelected boards systematically dismantle our health care services.

No here is the comment from Fional McMurran and report on bed closings from the Ontario Public Service Employees Union.

A Comment From Fiona McMurran

Oh, the good news just keeps on coming, doesn’t  it?

The Director of Care of the seniors’ residence where my elderly Dad  lives (in the Ottawa area, since his hospitalization earlier this year, who has 30 years  experience as a nurse, told us that in Ottawa, patients who stubbornly refuse  to die within a three-week period are sent back to their own homes or to long-term care homes,  rather than “clutter up” hospital and/or palliative care beds.

What have we  come to in this province?
OPSEU Report – Hamilton-Niagara  Region Loses 181 complex Care Beds In Faulty “Right-Sizing” Plan

Fifty-eight more complex care beds are scheduled to close after the  Hamilton Niagara Haldimand Brant Local Health Integration Network (HNHB LHIN)  approved a plan that will take “continuing” out of “complex continuing care.”  That brings to 181 the number of complex care beds that have been cut since  last December.

Under the new plan complex care patients will be limited to those seeking between 45 and 90 days of care, including those seeking end  of life care.

The HNHB LHIN claims it is right-sizing the number of  beds based on a formula that takes into consideration the number of alternate  level of care (ALC) patients occupying the beds, an adjustment for population  growth, a calculation of unmet need, and an assumption that 92 per cent of the  beds will be occupied at any one time. The task force does not give us the  data in which they made these calculations.

Instead of looking at  average occupancy to determine present use, the LHIN task force simply took a  one-day snapshot which indicated 590 complex care (CC) patients were occupying  beds. These patients fit the new definition of complex care, and therefore  would not include ALC patients.

At present there are 686 beds  available. 590 patients represent an 86 per cent occupancy rate – considered  by many health administrators to be full occupancy. Yet somehow the report  also claims between 35 per cent and 38 per cent of the beds are occupied by  ALC patients. How could that be, given it adds up to 121 to 124 per  cent?

At 92 per cent occupancy, CC patients would occupy 577 beds based  on the new target of 628 beds – that’s 13 beds less than their one day  snapshot. In addition, if they calculated for a five per cent unmet need,  based on 590 patients, they would need to find an additional 29.5 beds. They  claim their calculations also include population growth. Unless “growth” was  negative, this definitely does not add up.

The task force neglects to  report on what the average length of stay presently is for a complex care  patient. Given they knocked “continuing” out the title, one would expect many  of these patients to be long-term. What happens to these patients is never  defined.

How the LHIN and the hospital determine which CC patients are  ALC is an interesting question, given new criteria for overall admission to CC  includes completion of the acute phase of illness, completion of the major  portion of diagnostic tests, and the fact that the patient is no longer  requiring acute daily medical intervention by a physician. This is very  similar to the definition of ALC.

The report also redistributes beds by  sub-region within the LHIN. The biggest loser would be the Niagara region,  which would lose 41 beds. This compounds other losses under the Niagara Health  System. Hamilton would lose 24 beds and Brant would lose 18 beds. Burlington  would gain 23 beds while Haldimand-Norfolk would gain two beds – just months  after cutting 10 complex care beds.

The plan also envisions a greater  role for the Community Care Access Centres, which are to provide assistance to  hospitals in placement of individuals currently designated ALC into more  appropriate settings. However, with no new long term care beds and home care  at capacity, it is unclear where the CCAC would be placing these  individuals.

The task force needs to give us the complete formula on  how they made their calculations. A back of the napkin calculation would  suggest there is a reason the numbers have not been filled in on the report –  it’s because they don’t add up.

Add a comment to this post <>

(Click on Niagara At Large at for more news and commentary on matters of interest and concern to our greater binational Niagara region.)

One response to “Cuts To Hospital Services In Niagara, Ontario And Other Regions Of Province Just Keep On Coming

  1. Linda McKellar

    Where is the public in all of this?! They can’t expect people like Sue, Fiona, Pat and Joy to do it all by themselves. If the public continues to sit on their collective butts, they’ll get just what they deserve – nothing!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.