Ford’s Tory Cabal Won’t Let Canada’s Charter Of Rights Stop It From Gutting Toronto’s City Council

Does Ford’s Ontario Election Win Put His Government Above The Law? He Seems To Think So.

A Brief Commentary by Doug Draper

Posted September 11th, 2018 on Niagara At Large

This past July, Doug Ford’s then barely four-week old Ontario government shocked people across the province with a sudden announcement that he had tabled legislation – Bill 5 or what he and his Tories where calling the “Better Local Government Act” – that would slash the number of seats on Toronto city council in half and cancel elections at large for regional council chairs in Niagara, York, Peel and Muskoka.

Doug Ford won’t let a little thing like Canada’s Charter of Rights stop him from imposing his will at the municipal government level.

Ford made his announcement just hours before the deadline for people to register their papers as candidates in this October 22nd municipal elections – causing many to question why he would mandate such significant changes without consultation and when the municipal election process was already underway.

The City of Toronto chose to challenge Ford’s ‘Bettter Local Government Act’ in the courts. Niagara, Peel, York and Muskoka did not. And this past Monday, September 10th, Ontario Superior Court Justice Edward Belobaba ruled that with respect to the moves Ford was making on Toronto at least – to slash the number of seats on its city council from 47 to 25 – those constitute a violation of the democratic freedoms enshrined in Canada’s Charter of Rights.

Doug Ford says he is the one standing up for democratic rights and freedoms

Then, within hours of the judge’s ruling, there was Ford announcing that he will not only use who knows how much tax money to appeal it, he will also go to draconian lengths to use the Charter of Right’s “notwithstanding clause” – usually reserved for emergencies that rise to the level of a major disaster, war or terrorist attack – to walk over the rights cited by the judge and do what he wants to do to Toronto’s city council anyway.

And why is he going to such drastic lengths?

According to him, it is because the judge, who dared to question the constitutionality of something he was doing, was appointed and he is the leader of a democratically elected government. Furthermore, Ford said he would not hesitate to reach for the notwithstanding clause again he felt it was necessary to impose his will, even if it means overriding the rights and freedoms of others.

Ford earned a reputation as a bully during the years he sat on Toronto city council and road shotgun for his late brother Rob when he was mayor. Now here he is bringing the same conduct and character to Ontario politics on the grounds that he won a provincial election with 38 per cent of the vote.

This guy is already behaving like a bully and dictator at the provincial level, and unless members of his caucus show the courage to restrain him, we have over three and a half more years of this.

Here is the Ford government’s September 10th media release on its determination to move over, despite court ruling based on constitutional law, with the slashing of Toronto’s city council. What municipal government in the province will Ford go after next?

News Release

Doug Ford Announces Action to Uphold the Better Local Government Act

Released September 10, 2018

Will call back the Legislature and invoke Section 33 of the Constitution to ensure the Better Local Government Act remains in effect as passed by Ontario’s democratically elected Legislature



Ontario Premier Doug Ford announced (this September 10th) that his government will take immediate action to ensure the Better Local Government Act remains in effect as passed by Ontario’s democratically elected legislature. 

“Canada’s Constitution makes it clear. The province has exclusive responsibility over municipalities,” said Ford in announcing his government’s action. “The Better Local Government Act will reduce the size and cost of government while reducing dysfunction at City Hall.

The people who are most vocal and fighting this move are a small group of left-wing councillors looking to continue their free ride on the taxpayers’ dollar and a network of activist groups who have entrenched their power under the status quo.”

Ford announced that his government will immediately recall Ontario’s Legislature and introduce legislation that, if passed, will invoke Section 33 of the Constitution and ensure the Better Local Government Act is preserved in time for the October 22 Municipal Election. 

Ford also announced that his government will immediately appeal Judge Belobaba’s decision to the Ontario Court of Appeal.

“I believe this decision is deeply concerning and wrong and the result is unacceptable to the people of Ontario,” concluded Ford.  “If you want to make new laws in Ontario – or in Canada – you first must seek a mandate from the people.”

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space following the Bernie Sanders quote below.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater bi-national Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

 “A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders


3 responses to “Ford’s Tory Cabal Won’t Let Canada’s Charter Of Rights Stop It From Gutting Toronto’s City Council

  1. If Ford were concerned with democracy in Ontario rather than behaving as a spoiled child bully his act would apply to the whole province not one city. Ford was elected premier of the province not elected to concentrate his vengeance on one city in the province. Because this act applies only to address a situation in Toronto the not withstanding clause should not be used. The not withstanding clause should be used if it applies to the province.


  2. Here are the stats.
    In the 2018 Ontario election-
    PC 40.5% of vote……….2,326,632 votes.
    NDP 33.6% of vote…….1,929,649 votes.
    Liberal 19.5% of vote….1,124,218 votes.
    Green 4.6% of vote…….264,478 votes.
    PC 2,326,632 votes….other parties 3,318,345 votes. How is this a majority?
    Almost a million voted against the PC’s!!! This is as stupid as the electoral college letting Trump win and that’s not where the comparisons stop. Both are bullies and egomaniacs with grudges and delusions of grandeur, out for themselves, not the populace or country/province.

    That 40.5% of the vote gave the PC’s SEVENTY SIX seats while the NDP with 33.6% got only FORTY seats. The PC’s got almost twice as many seats with only 7% more votes than the NDP and fewer votes by far than the total of the opposition parties yet they have a “majority”!!!!!!!!!
    This means the PC were outvoted by an approximate % of 40.5 to 57.7. that does NOT represent a majority and so does not represent the people. The same paradigm exists from municipal to federal governments.
    How does this give a mandate to run rampant over the rights of voters and alter the election procedures of the entire province on a whim?
    Time for TRUE representative democracy that does not allow an egomaniac bearing grudges to overrule the majority.
    Furthermore the voter turnout was just over 50%.
    Whose fault is this? – #1 lackadaisical voters who can’t be bothered to get off their asses and vote and, #2 – idiots who vote without studying the real issues.


  3. My apologies but my remark should be edited for clarity….almost a million more voted AGAINST the PC’s than FOR the PC’s, 2 million for the PC’s versus 3 million AGAINST them.

    As you said Doug, the “notwithstanding clause” is designed for a crisis or national emergency!!!!! This is neither!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.