Ford Government’s “Better Local Government Act” Is An Assault On Municipal Council Candidate’s  Constitutional Freedoms – Ontario Superior Court Judge

Judge’s September 10th Ruling Applies To Toronto Only. What About The Freedoms Of Candidates Impacted By Ford’s Act – Also Known As Bill 5 – In Niagara & Three Other Ontario Regions?

A News Commentary by Doug Draper

Posted September 10th, 2018 on Niagara At Large

Ontario Superior Court Judge slaps down Doug Ford’s move to slash size of Toronto council. Ford’s cancellation of Niagara-wide elections for regional council chair reportedly  remains untouched. Ford is already vowing to overturn the judge’s ruling on the grounds that his Tory Party  was elected on a promise to reduce the size of government .

An Ontario Superior Court Judge began this week  of Monday, September 10th by delivering a serious blow to the part of Premier Doug Ford’s so-called  “Better Local Government Act” that would slash the number of Toronto city councillors following this October 22nd municipal elections from 47 to 25.

Unfortunately, the Judge’s ruling reportedly did nothing to overturn or address that part of Ford’s bill that – suddenly and without warning this past July 27th – cancelled region-wide elections in Niagara, York, Peel and Muskoka for who will serve for the next four years, as Chair of Regional Council in those four regions.

That part of the bill that cancelled elections for Chair in Niagara and the other three regions – tabled by Ford, without any apparent warning, on the last day  for registering as a candidate – left those who had registered to run for Chair in Niagara, including Pelham Mayor Dave Augustyn and incumbent Al Caslin, scrambling to re-register as candidates for a regional council seat in their respective municipalities of Pelham and St. St. Catharines.

Another individual who had earlier launched a campaign to run for Regional Chair – a former Welland mayor, Damian Goulbourne, decided not to re-register as a candidate for one of the two directly elected regional council seats in Welland.

Pelham Mayor Dave Augustyn officially announces his decision this past July to run for Niagara regional chair, only to have his region-wide campaign for that position cancelled out by Ford’s government. Now he is running in Pelham for a regional council seat.

Augustyn and others across Niagara, including the area’s NDP MPPs, condemned Ford’s ‘Better Local Government Act’ as an “assault on local democracy,” but only the City of Toronto decided to challenge the legislation in the courts.

In his ruling this September 10th, Ontario Superior Court Judge Edward Belobaba said the Act, imposed as it was by Ford, on the final morning residents across the province had an opportunity to register as a candidate for municipal office in this October’s elections, constitutes a “violation “of a municipal candidate’s “freedom of expression that is guaranteed under (Canada’s) Charter of Rights.”

The Judge also ruled that the significant reduction in the number of council seats and wards in Toronto, “from an average of about 61,000 (city residents per ward) to 111,000 substantially interfered with the municipal voter’s freedom of expression under … the Charter of Rights.”

Judge Belobaba went on to conclude that these violations of the Charter “cannot be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.”

Within hours of the ruling’s release,  Ford responded  by declaring that his self-described “Government for the People” will appeal it and will also be go so far as to – for the first time in Ontario history – employ the Charter’s “notwithstanding clause,”   usually reserved for emergencies on the level of an act of war or terrorist attack, to re-introduce the part of the legislation that slashes Toronto’s council as soon as possible.

According to Ford, it is appropriate for him to make this unprecedented move because he – unlike the “appointed judge” – is the leader of a democratically elected majority government and because he is acting to fulfill a promise he made in last spring’s provincial election to reduce the size of government.

However, Ford never specifically said  he was thinking of halving the number of seats on Toronto’s council.  Nor did he ever hint, prior to last June’s vote, that he would cancel a decision by Ontario’s former Liberal government  to allow general elections for  council chairs in Niagara and the three other regions, and allow a continuation of a decades-old practice of having chair’s elected by other members of council.

Niagara Region’s current Chair, Al Caslin, was never keen for region-wide elections for his position anyway. He and a number of other regional councillors favoured a status quo that has councillors electing the chair.

A majority on Niagara’s current Caslin-led regional council voted against the idea of electing the char at large when it was raised three years ago by representatives from the Greater Niagara Chamber of Commerce. Some regional councillors argued, rather paternallistically, that they are better able to choose a suitable individual to serve as chair than voters at large.

For this term of the Region’s council, a majority of the councillors chose Caslin, who now finds himself enmeshed in controversy over the 2016 hiring of the Region’s current CAO, Carmen D’Angelo, and his more recent decision to unilaterally extend D’Angelo’s contract and allegedly write in terms that would pay out more money to D’Angelo should this council or the next one choose, for some reason, to let him go.

When Ford decided last July 27th to cancel region-wide elections for the chair’s position, a Canadian Press story reported that Caslin greeted the decision “as welcome news.”

“We’re back where we started, I guess,” Caslin said.

We are back where we started, alright.

And if all of the last-minute pulling the rug out from under plans for region-wide elections for the chair  in Niagara and three other regions isn’t enough, now Ford and company are charging off like a a herd of rogue elephants to overturn the Judge’s ruling on the Toronto elections, just weeks before voters head to the polls.

All of this brought to us by a Ford government elected by less than 40 per cent of those who went to the polls in the provincial elections this past June.

It should have most Ontario residents shuttering over what this ‘buck-a-beer’ premier is going to do next.

Meanwhile, many of Ford’s critics are questioning why he has to move so fast to make such fundamental changes to municipal governance in Ontario. Why can’t the changes he wants to make be more carefully reviewed in consultation with members of the public in time for the 2022 municipal elections?

What is the big rush? And why aren’t region-wide elections for the Chair’s job good enough for voters in Niagara, Peel, York and Muskoka when other voters across Ontario have been picking the person to hold the top job on their councils for decades now?

Some exact wording from the Ontario Superior Court Judge’s ruling against the Ford government’s efforts to swiftly slash the size of Toronto’s council.

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space following the Bernie Sanders quote below.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater bi-national Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

 “A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders



One response to “Ford Government’s “Better Local Government Act” Is An Assault On Municipal Council Candidate’s  Constitutional Freedoms – Ontario Superior Court Judge

  1. The NDP doesn’t want to waste tax dollars on an appeal! Ford has a new ally at Queen’s Park. He must be laughing.
    I believed in a society of laws. It is now ending with a whimper.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.