Conservation Authority and its former CAO Sue Niagara Resident for $200,000

By Doug Draper

Posted January 12, 2017 on Niagara At Large

It has been a threat that the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority has held over the head of St. Catharines/Niagara resident Ed Smith since last fall.

Ed Smith - a community activist and resident of Niagara, Ontario - has been slapped with a $200,000 lawsuit by the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority and its former CAO (now Niagara Region's CAO) Carmen D'Angelo.

Ed Smith – a community activist and resident of Niagara, Ontario – has been slapped with a $200,000 lawsuit by the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority and its former CAO (now Niagara Region’s CAO) Carmen D’Angelo.

Now the NPCA and its former CAO and recently hired CAO for Niagara’s regional government, Carmen D’Angelo,. have followed trough on their threat to sue Smith – a retired Canadian Armed Forces officer and a community leader in calling for a full forensic audit and investigation of the NPCA’s operations – with a defamation suit totallying $200,000.

The move by the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority and its former CAO is virtually unprecedented in Niagara. It represents the first time in this region of Ontario and Canada that a body funded with public taxdollars, is suing a private citizen who has been pressing it for more accountability and transparency when it comes to growing citizen concerns that have been raised about its hiring and firing practices, its land dealings, how and who it awards contacts to, and other matters.

In a statement circulated to the media at large this January 12th, Smith has this to –

“I was served notice by NPCA legal counsel on November 14th 2016.  The letter of notice included a list of demands for my compliance; failure to comply could result in further legal action.

In that letter the demands made by the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority (NPCA), a government agency, can be paraphrased in part as:

  1. you will deliver a full and unqualified written apology for distributing the report,
  2. you will deliver a written Undertaking confirming that you will not distribute the document to any other persons and that you will not make similar statements about the NPCA in the future, and
  3. you will provide the identity of the author(s) of the document.

These were demands made on behalf of a Board comprised of 11 of our Regional Councillors on a citizen of Canada.

I did not agree to the three demands.”

Smith’s statement goes on to conclude –

“On the 22nd of December 2016 the NPCA (our government) along with with Carmen D’Angelo, the now-Chair of the Niagara Region, launched a civil action against me seeking $200,000 for defamation ($100,000 each).

It is my intent to defend myself against this action to the fullest extent.  I have said it before and I will say it now, this is Governance run amok.  That any government in Canada can sue a citizen for defamation, or even believes that it should, speaks of arrogance and a complete lack of understanding of the true principles of our democracy.

The NPCA is using taxpayer funding to sue a citizen.

I remain steadfast in my pursuit for transparency, accountability and good governance at the NPCA and I will not be intimidated by lawsuits. Let the leadership of the NPCA (our elected Regional Councillors) be held accountable.

Bruce Timms (NPCA’s chair and a St. Catharines regional councillor) claims the NPCA is a model of transparency and accountability.  The upcoming court case will certainly cast some light on that.”

This past November, Niagara At Large reported that Welland Riding (provincial) MPP Cindy Forster piublicly joined Smith in calling on the Ontario government to launch a full audit and inviestigation of the NPCA’s operations.

Those calls were followed by similar ones made by the cities of St. Catharines, Port Colborne, Welland, Thorold and Hamilton and the towns of Pelham and Niagara-on-the-Lake – an unprecedented show of non-confidence in a public body by municipal councils representing a major of the people in this region and neighouring Hamilton

So far, Ontario’s Minister of Natural Resources, Kathryn McGarry, has said no to the province initiating an audit and investigation – passing the buck to municipal authorities even though the NPCA and its sister agencies across the province are creatures of the Ontario Conservation Act.

Niagara At Large will have far more to say about all of this in news and commentary posted here in the hours and days ahead.

Please stay tuned.

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space below the Bernie quote.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater binational Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

 “A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders


5 responses to “Conservation Authority and its former CAO Sue Niagara Resident for $200,000

  1. James Vanderburgh

    Great Work!
    What is wrong with a citizens) questioning what is actually happening with our tax dollars? Polititians should only be allowed 2 terms one in office and one in jail! I told this joke to Bruce Timms and he did not laugh!


  2. The world is taking on the Trump paradigm. If you don’t like someone’s actions, threaten to sue.


  3. There is an ancient saying that whom is to be destroyed is first made mad. This can be seen in this law suit. It will ultimately cause those who made it to be pushed into greater disrepute.


  4. We are entering a very scary period of time. Since when is it okay to sue a citizen who is raising legitimate issues about publicly funded organization? Because it sues, the principals must be so thin-skinned or have something to hide, methinks?


  5. I suspect that this is going to make matters much worse for the NPCA. The optics are bad, and if this case goes to discovery we are going to learn a lot more.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s