The Tragedy of Losing Our Locally Owned News Outlets to Corporate Chains

Remembering The St. Catharines Standard when it was still owned by the Burgoyne Family

By Niagara At Large reporter and publisher Doug Draper

Posted February 3rd, 2022 on Niagara At Large

The St. Catharines Standard’s last great publisher, Henry Burgoyne

With a recent health scare  leaving me a little more mindful of my own mortality, I was reminded that it was 11 years ago this February that the last great daily newspaper publisher I ever worked for died.

His name was Henry Burgoyne, who died at age 61 in February, 2011 following a long, brave battle with cancer.

Henry was among the fourth generation of the St. Catharines-based Burgoyne family who owned and operated The Standard since it was purchased by his great grandfather, William B. Burgoyne for one dollar from a failing owner 1892.

Henry became The Standard’s publisher in 1975,  four years before I was hired and five years before he and my managing editor agreed to assign me to cover environmental issues in our region – making the newspaper one of the very first of its size in Canada to have a full-time environment beat.

During my more than a decade and a half as environment reporter at The Standard, I am proud to say that we were able to shine a hot light on many crimes being committed against our local and Great Lakes waters, our lands and the air that we breathe – enough to rally provincial and federal environment agencies into action.

Henry Burgoyne, during the Standard’s last golden years as an independently owned daily newspaper in Niagara,. Ontaro

The coverage brought me my share of awards and requests to speak at conferences on both sides of the Canada-U.S. border and I always made sure I gave credit to Henry and his family for investing enough resources in the newsroom to make the depth of coverage I was able to do possible.

That kind of commitment to news coverage usually only comes from newspaper owners who, like the Burgoynes, have roots in the community and care about the community and its people.

Then one day the corporate sharks came in and it was all over.

The environment beat, along with a number of other full-time beats at the newspaper, focused on education, health, labour and other key areas of interest to the community, disappeared as, beginning in 1996, The Standard fell into the hands of one corporate chain after another that hollowed the resources of the newsroom out.

Like some of the other reporters and editors from the Burgoyne era, I tried toughing it out for a few more years but it became gut-wrenching to watch what they were doing to a once-great community newspaper.

According to the hatchet men these corporate chains sent in to run the newspaper, it wasn’t even a newspaper anymore. It was a “product.” Our readers out there in the community were no longer readers, they were “customers.” And we were told to give up editorial policies that had guided news coverage for decades for a “business plan” that among other things, allowed the advertising department to compromise and corrupt what passed for the “news” the paper would cover.

After a few years of this, I joined a number of other reporters in taking advantage of a buy-out package we had negotiated to get the hell out of there.

Last year, three or four Niagara At Large readers reminded me of a St. Catharines segment of TVO series I was interviewed for called ‘Main Street, Ontario’. A brief outline TVO produced for the St. Catharines segment reads as follows; “The St. Catharines Standard was at the forefront of breaking news during the golden age of newspapers. Run by four generations of the Burgoyne family, The Standard’s intrepid reporters delivered hard-hitting journalism and exposed environmental injustices. But times changed, and media consolidation hit the paper hard.”

You can watch this segment by clicking on the screen immediately below. But before you do I want to pay respect to the few journalists left at newspapers like The Standard who are trying to do a job that five to ten times there number were able to do when the newspapers were truly local and independent. It is not their fault f they fall short. Blame it on the corporate vultures that put higher and higher profit margins ahead of investing the resources in high quality news coverage.

Before the COVID plague overtook us in early 2020, I began talking to others in Niagara about how we might be able to build on Niagara At Large as a truly independent news and commentary source in Niagara, Ontario. But the virus put an end to any further planning on that.

Perhaps we can get back to it in the foreseeable future. I hope so.

If enough of us care to, we can work together to bring back a locally, owned and operated, independent news outlet for residents across Niagara,

  • Doug Draper, Niagara At Large

To read more on Henry Burgoyne and the once independent, locally owned Standard by Doug Draper and by two of my former newsroom colleagues at the newspaper, click on the following links – https://niagaraatlarge.com/2011/02/08/henry-burgoyne-was-without-doubt-the-last-great-publisher-of-a-daily-newspaper-in-niagara-ontario/

https://niagaraatlarge.com/2011/02/09/an-%E2%80%98unpretentious-publisher%E2%80%99-who-always-put-the-news-people-in-niagara-needed-to-know-first/ .

NIAGARA AT LARGE Encourages You To Join The Conversation By Sharing Your Views On This Post In The Space Following The Bernie Sanders Quote Below.

“A Politician Thinks Of The Next Election. A Leader Thinks Of The Next Generation.” – Bernie Sanders

Advertisement

5 responses to “The Tragedy of Losing Our Locally Owned News Outlets to Corporate Chains

  1. Hi Doug, I remember Henry Burgoyne quite clearly. When I was a working student at Coy’s Hardware, I remember he bought a nice big bar from them. I got sent over to the Standard office with a heavy cardboard box containing some expensive scotch for him as a gift.

    Later, when I worked at CHSC (which is when I got to know you), I ran into him at functions as well.

    The demise of the Standard began when a crooked lady in the classified ads section began skimming cash. I think she took over a million bucks before she was caught, and she wasted it all on shopping sprees – she was literally a shopping addict. They never got the money back and ended up having to sell out – not sure if it was to Torstar originally or if they later acquired it.

    Now Trudeau has his media support fund, a disgrace if there ever was one. If he would just level the advertising playing field by forcing companies like Google to pay tax on their revenue derived from Canada, it would go a long way to help our Canadian media.

    Anyway, keep up the good work you are still doing, and very glad you’re back!

    Cheers,

    Tim

    Like

  2. Well said.
    Well written.
    An emotional and honest remembrance.
    Like many, I read The Standard through the ’60s, ’70s, ’80s, ’90s and still do.
    Doug, I remember many of your articles and awards.

    Like

  3. I also have fond memories of Henry, both professionally as a Standard reporter and editor, and personally. I can’t believe it’s been 11 years since Henry’s death. It was always a pleasure to work alongside you, Doug.

    Like

  4. So true Doug. I was working at CHCH, when it was purchased by Global in 2001. When Izzy Asper asked one of his newsrooms (not ours) what they thought was their purpose? The response was predictable. “we provide timely and accurate news to our community” his response was “No, you sell soap”

    Like

  5. The big corporations always take and never put anything back. When everything is sucked out of the company they sell to a new group who repeats the process until there is nothing left. My heart goes out to those still in the industry who always have to do more with less. When owners of newspapers do not live in that community they just don’t care. When I hear young people say newspapers are dead and everything can be found online, that’s just not true. Do you agree or disagree?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.