Short Hills Deer Hunt Protesters Offer Regrets for Words “Perceived To Be” Offensive on Facebook Page

Protesters Say They “sincerely regret that comments were posted on NAfA’s (Niagara Action for Animal’s) Facebook page that were perceived to be hateful, threatening and/or discriminatory in any way, and that these comments were not  immediately called out.”

A Statement from Niagara Action for Animals (NAfA) and Short Hills Wildlife Alliance (SHWA)

Posted November 8th, 2019 on Niagara At Large

A Brief Foreword by Doug Draper at Niagara At Large –

Niagara Action for Animals (NAfA) and the Short Hills Wildlife Alliance (SHWA) issued the following statement this November 7th, a day after reports appeared in Niagara daily newspapers about vile words and comments appearing on NAfA’s Facebook page.

Deer hunt opponents gather for protest at Short Hills Provincial Park in Niaara, Ontario

The ugly words were aimed at members of the Indigenous community who, with the blessing now of two Ontario governments (the former Liberals and now Doug Ford’s Conservatives) exercise their Aboriginal Treaty rights each year around this time to hunt deer for a few days in Short Hills Provincial Park in Niagara.

The Indigenous deer hunt in the park has repeatedly been met with animal activist groups and some of the residents living around the park holding protest demonstrations at park entrances.

Another one of the signs that have greeted Indigenous hunters at Short Hills Park

The offensive comments on NAfA’s Facebook page, which have recently been taken down by the group, including some supporters of the protests calling the Indigenous hunters “drunks” and “barbarians,” and saying that rather than the deer, they are the ones who should be “harvested.”

The language was condemned as inexcusable and sickening by members of the Indigenous community and by some of Niagara’s elected representatives, including St. Catharines Mayor Walter Sendzik. Niagara At Large posted its own condemnation of these hateful words this November 7th on this site.

Here is the full statement  from NAfA and SHWA responding to these expressions of disappointment and outrage over what appeared on the Facebook page.

Niagara At Large emailed a copy of this statement to a representative of the Indigenous community for a response but did not yet hear back at the time of this posting. We will post a response from the community if and when we receive one.

Meanwhile, here it is for you to read and you are free to share your response in the comment space at the bottom of this post –

Niagara Action for Animals (NAfA) and Short Hills Wildlife Alliance (SHWA) acknowledge that the Indigenous peoples of Canada have historically suffered discrimination, abuse and mistreatment at the hands of individuals, governments, religious institutions and more, and that they continue to deal with these issues today.

Members of the Indigenous community gather for one of the hunts in Short Hills provincial Park past six years.

NAfA and SHWA do not encourage, condone, support or solicit discriminatory or abusive attitudes, comments or actions towards Indigenous peoples, under any circumstance.

NAfA and SHWA sincerely regret that comments were posted on NAfA’s Facebook page that were perceived to be hateful, threatening and/or discriminatory in any way, and that these comments were not immediately called out.

These comments do not represent the position of NAfA or SHWA.

Moving forward, steps are being taken to ensure that this type of language is not perpetuated in the future.

For 50 years, Short Hills Provincial Park was a place of peace, conservation, harmony and sanctuary for its animal inhabitants.

NAfA’s mission is to educate the public about the issues  surrounding the abuse, exploitation, mistreatment, or killing of animals for entertainment, clothing, food, sport, or research.

SHWA’s mission is to protect the sanctity and safety of Short Hills Park, promote peaceful coexistence with wildlife, and act as a strong voice for the land, its inhabitants, and visitors within the park.

Therefore, both NAfA’s and SHWA’s objections to hunting in Short Hills Provincial Park has always been about the suffering and death of the deer, not who the hunters are.

NAfA and SHWA would, and do, have the same objection to hunting done by non-Indigenous people. NAfA and SHWA will always stand against the abuse, exploitation and killing of animals.

Niagara Action for Animals (NAfA) or is a non-profit, all volunteer charity devoted to ending all forms of animal cruelty through education, direct action and legitimate protest.

For more information on NAfA and its animal advocacy work, click on –

To read a commentary written by Doug Draper and posted on  Niagara At Large this November 7th on this matter, click on – .

Now it is your turn to share your comment on this issue, if you would care to below. 

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space following the Bernie Sanders quote below.

A Reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For More News And Commentary From Niagara At Large – An independent, alternative voice for our greater bi-national Niagara Region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

“A Politician Thinks Of The Next Election. A Leader Thinks Of The Next Generation.” – Bernie Sanders


2 responses to “Short Hills Deer Hunt Protesters Offer Regrets for Words “Perceived To Be” Offensive on Facebook Page

  1. Short Hills Provincial Park should be a place of peace, conservation, harmony and sanctuary for its animal inhabitants, birds and plants. No hunting by anyone should be allowed here. Definitely no vehicles. We need to learn respect for our lands. People have lost respect in all aspects of life.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. We don’t own this rock. The choice is between endorsing suffering and death or opposing it – for all species. People have the freedom to object to the Short Hills deer hunt without being branded racists – hunting in the park is not an activity that’s traditionally been granted to ANYONE, therefore, no one is purporting that indigenous people should be denied an activity in which others are legally partaking. All concerns have been addressed not towards “who” is doing the hunting, but that it is occurring at all in a “No Hunt Park.” There is an urgent need to protect the integrity of the park; this cannot and does not always look like politeness.

    It’s unfortunate that some social media commenters chose to express themselves inappropriately and with poor impulse control, but these were deemed not criminally-actionable. The hunt supports and media do not have any legitimate indictments against the anti-hunt demonstrators without hyper-partisan selection of “facts” at the expense of fairness. What their disinformation and doxxing campaigns seek is to impact agenda setting, muddy the informational waters, and intimidate critics of the hunt into silence.

    According to FOIA documents I ordered from both the OPP and the NRP, only one social media post was ever reviewed at and it was dismissed straight-away as a non-issue. These social media posts are not actionable – there are no credible, direct threats to any individual. The OPP by their own admission, did not even open a case. There was nothing to document.

    A Reply from Niagara At Large reporter Doug Draper – This journalist, as members of Niagara Action for Animals well know, has long been supportive of their efforts to advocate for animals, and has had a record of opposing hunting deer in this provincial park, which has long been treated as a nature sanctuary.

    However, some of the comments aimed at the Indigenous hunters went beyond defending, and at least borderlined on being offensive and racist to members of First Nations people that have long experienced the negative and sometimes lethal behaviour of settlers to this region of the world.

    I would suggest that it makes far more sense to aim any protest against this annual hunt at the Ontario government, where it belongs. – Regards, Doug Draper


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.