Niagara Loses One Of Its Very Best With Bill Hodgson’s Decision Not To Run For Regional Council Again

Maybe We Don’t Deserve Good People Like Bill Hodgson in Municipal Politics. Do We?

A News Commentary by Doug Draper

Posted July 5th, 2018 on Niagara At Large 

Bill Hodgson, on his way into an NPCA board meeting in April, 2017, where he was censured behind closed doors. Soon after, he would resign from the board. File photo by Doug Draper

“My whole spirit of community service is crushed. I just feel discouraged. I don’t see an end to the nasty, self-serving people.”

Those were among the words Lincoln regional councillor Bill Hodgson shared with a local newspaper this July 4th to explain why, after 25 years of public service, he has decided not to run for another term of regional council in Niagara.

Crushed. Discouraged. Those two feelings have shaken his spirit, to say the least.

This decent, honest and caring man – three of the qualities that have always glowed from the only Bill Hodgson I have known going back to his earliest days as a school board trustee in Niagara and mine as a reporter at The St. Catharine’s Standard – has also found himself a target of the kind of political bludgeoning that has left others wondering why any good person in this region would want to run for elected office in the first place.

“I feel bad about this and I’ve already had some people tell me that if I don’t run, then they win,” he told me after I called him about the newspaper report this July 5th. “But I can’t go back,” he said, before going on to explain how much all of the stress around being attacked has taken a toll on his health and his family.

“It is a high energy role and if you run out of energy you have a responsibility to your community to step aside if you can’t do your due diligence anymore.”

One year ago this spring, on April 26th, 2017, Bill Hodgson walked into a meeting of the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority where he had served for the Town of Lincoln as a board member. The doors of the meeting room were then swung shut with a sign reading; “Meeting is in Closed Session,” and with sheets of paper taped over the glass on the doors so those of us who came to attend the meeting could not see in.

The signs the public faced on the papered over doors of the NPCA board meeting room while Bill Hodgson was being censured inside. File photo by Doug Draper

Inside that closed room, in front senior NPCA managers and a board that includes 10 other politicians he sits on Niagara’s regional council with and who he then sat on the Conservation Authority’s board with, he was summarily “censured” for reasons that had something to do with some email he apparently passed on to one of the managers about a private consultant interested in doing a forensic audit of the NPCA’s operations.

He was accused of committing some impropriety in whatever process the NPCA had going at the time for choosing a firm to do an audit, but was never made privy to whatever is contained in a lawyer’s report the board used to censure him.

A month later, in May of last year, Bill Hodgson returned to the same meeting room just long enough to tender his letter of resignation from the board.

Bill Hodgson,, left, with Niagara citizen activist Ed Smith, who was still facing an NPCA lawsuit (a lawsuit that was eventually dismissed by an Ontario judge), shortly after Hodgson tendered his letter of resignation from the NPCA board in May of 2017. File photo by Doug Draper

Apparently, The Standard now has a copy of this lawyer’s report that was kept under wraps for so long by an NPCA that brags ad nauseam about being an Ontario-wide “leader in transparency.”

But whatever this report says, the one thing members of the public and some of our local l and provincial representatives who’ve been raising concerns about the NPCA and how it is spends millions of tax dollars know is this.

Bill Hodgson, while still a member of that board, tried to do his part to see that an independent forensic audit of the NPCA’s operations is done. And in the wake of those attempts, he walked into a board meeting one morning where the doors were papered over and some of the people who pay those taxes were shut out, and he was censured in a way that left him feeling that he had no choice but to resign.

And in the wake of that, not one other member of that board, some who have sat on municipal councils with Bill Hodgson for years and should have known what a decent person he is, showed the courage or decency themselves to stand up publicly in defense of him.

A few months later, when the NPCA’s board chair, Fort Erie regional councillor Sandy Annunziata, stood before the Town of Lincoln’s council in a chambers were Bill Hodgson once served as mayor, the town’s current mayor, Sandra Easton, didn’t even show enough decency to speak up for a person who has represented her community with class for the past 25 years.

Shame on all of them and one can only hope that their role in all of this is remembered this coming October 22nd when we get to cast our votes in municipal elections.

Perhaps the only fortunate thing that has come out of this sorry episode to date is that Ontario’s Auditor General’s Office finally did launch an audit of the NPCA’s operations, although it wouldn’t be surprising now if the new provincial government simply tosses in the trash any conclusions or recommendations that come out of that probe.

Unfortunately, we lose a good person like Bill Hodgson and if enough people in this Niagara region do not get engaged and vote other good people on to our local and regional councils this coming October, he will be right when he says; “I don’t see an end to the nasty, self-serving people.”

It is up to all of us – you and I and everyone else who is of voting age in this region – to wake up, get more involved, and make sure that isn’t true!

See an online story The St. Catharines Standard posted on this by clicking on .

For news commentaries, Niagara At Large posted last year on this matter, click on .

And click on this one about the cowardice of the current mayor of Lincoln around not speaking out for Bill Hodgson when the NPCA chair visited her council last year .

This sign was also posted outside the NPCA board meeting room this past 2017. Apparently it was intended for members of the public.

NIAGARA AT LARGE encourages you to join the conversation by sharing your views on this post in the space following the Bernie Sanders quote below.

A reminder that we only post comments by individuals who also share their first and last names.

For more news and commentary from Niagara At Large – an independent, alternative voice for our greater bi-national Niagara region – become a regular visitor and subscriber to NAL at .

“A politician thinks of the next election. A leader thinks of the next generation.” – Bernie Sanders

2 responses to “Niagara Loses One Of Its Very Best With Bill Hodgson’s Decision Not To Run For Regional Council Again

  1. Gail Benjafield

    Integrity, service to the local community, committed, open and honest about all issues is the Hodgson I knew. The NPCA has much to answer for, in its apparent cover up of its firing of qualified staff, its promotion of those from within … and on it goes.


  2. No one said a good word about him? Noone? Shame on all of the politicians at Niagara Region. Everybody knows how it goes.
    We need a deep cleaning here in Niagara.

    A Brief Note from Niagara At Large reporter and publisher Doug Draper – I agree with Joe Gibbons that we need to vote for a big change in the October municipal elections. Just to clarify though, what my commentary on Bill Hodgson says is that not one politician on the Niagara Peninsula Conservation Authority – neither any of the directly elected regional councilors or the mayors sitting on the NPCA board – stood up publicly to defend Bill Hodgson. That was also true of Lincoln Mayor Sandra Easton, who does not sit on the NPCA board, but who had a chance to speak up for Hodgson when NPCA chair Sandy Annunziata spoke at one of her town council meetings weeks after Bill Hodgson was censured by the board. It was her opportunity to speak out for an individual who has served Lincoln with decency for more than two decades and she did not.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.